.png)
Last week, I met with a family in Felida who'd been arguing about water heaters for three days straight. The husband wanted tankless—"endless hot water!" The wife wanted tank—"we can't afford $6,000 right now!" Sound familiar? After 22 years installing both types across Vancouver, I've had this conversation hundreds of times. Here's what I told them (spoiler: they're both right).
Choosing between tank and tankless isn't about which one's "better"—it's about which one fits your situation. Your budget, your home's setup, how much hot water you use, and how long you plan to stay in your house all matter. Let me break down both options so you can make the right call for your family.
Understanding the Basics
Traditional Tank Water Heaters
Tank water heaters store and continuously heat 30-80 gallons of water in an insulated tank. When you turn on a hot water tap, hot water flows from the top of the tank and is replaced by cold water at the bottom, which is then heated.
These have been the standard in American homes for decades and are available in gas, electric, and propane models.
Tankless Water Heaters (On-Demand)
Tankless water heaters, also called on-demand or instantaneous water heaters, heat water directly as it flows through the unit—only when you need it. When you turn on a hot water tap, cold water travels through a heat exchanger where powerful burners or electric elements rapidly heat it to your desired temperature.
Because they don't store hot water, tankless systems are much more compact and can be mounted on walls.
Tank Water Heater: Pros and Cons
Advantages of Tank Water Heaters
- Lower upfront cost: Tank systems cost significantly less to purchase and install, making them budget-friendly
- Simple installation: Replacing an existing tank with a new one is straightforward and requires minimal modifications
- Works with any fuel type: Available in electric, natural gas, propane, and even oil models
- Familiar technology: Plumbers are universally trained on tank systems, making service and repairs widely available
- Handles simultaneous demand: Multiple people can use hot water at once without flow issues (until the tank depletes)
- No power outage concerns: Gas tank heaters work during power outages (electric ignition models may not)
Disadvantages of Tank Water Heaters
- Limited hot water supply: Once the tank is empty, you must wait 30-60 minutes for more hot water
- Standby heat loss: Constantly heating stored water wastes energy even when you're not using hot water
- Shorter lifespan: Typically need replacement after 10-15 years
- Takes up floor space: Requires a dedicated area in your basement, garage, or utility room
- Risk of catastrophic failure: A failing tank can release 30-80 gallons of water into your home
Tankless Water Heater: Pros and Cons
Advantages of Tankless Water Heaters
- Endless hot water: Never run out during long showers or when multiple people need hot water
- Energy efficiency: Only heats water when needed, saving 20-30% on water heating costs
- Longer lifespan: Lasts 20+ years with proper maintenance, nearly twice as long as tank heaters
- Space-saving design: Wall-mounted units free up valuable floor space
- No standby heat loss: No wasted energy keeping a tank of water hot 24/7
- Precise temperature control: Set your exact desired temperature
- Lower risk of water damage: No large tank that could burst and flood your home
Disadvantages of Tankless Water Heaters
- Higher upfront cost: Installation costs 2-3x more than a tank system, especially for gas units
- May require upgrades: Gas lines, venting, and electrical systems often need modifications
- Limited flow rate: If undersized, running multiple fixtures simultaneously can overwhelm the system
- Longer payback period: Takes 10-20 years to recoup the higher installation cost through energy savings
- Sensitive to hard water: Mineral buildup can damage heat exchangers; annual descaling maintenance required
What I Recommended to the Felida Family
Remember that couple I mentioned? After walking through their home, I noticed three things: their current gas line was already sized for higher demand, they had teenage kids who'd be leaving for college in 3-4 years, and their utility room was cramped.
I recommended they stick with a high-efficiency tank system for now. Here's why: their upfront budget was tight, their gas line wouldn't need expensive upgrades, and once the kids move out, their hot water demand will drop significantly. In 10-12 years when the tank needs replacing, they can reassess whether tankless makes sense for an empty-nester lifestyle.
The husband wasn't thrilled at first—until I showed him the math. The $4,200 they'd save on installation could go toward their daughter's college fund. That sealed the deal.
My Honest Take After 22 Years
Go tankless if: You're staying in your home 15+ years, have high hot water usage, your utility room is cramped, and you can afford the $3,500-$6,500 upfront cost. It'll pay for itself eventually.
Stick with tank if: You're on a tight budget, planning to move within 10 years, have moderate hot water needs, or your home would require major gas line upgrades for tankless.
One more thing: if you've got hard water here in SW Washington (and many of us do), budget for annual descaling on tankless units. I've seen $5,000 systems die at year 7 because homeowners skipped maintenance. Tank systems are more forgiving.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does it cost to install a tankless water heater in Vancouver WA?
In Vancouver WA, tankless installations typically range from $3,500-$6,500 depending on whether you need gas line upgrades, electrical work, or venting modifications. Tank water heaters cost $1,200-$2,500 installed.
Will a tankless water heater save me money on energy bills?
Yes, tankless systems are 20-30% more energy-efficient because they only heat water on demand. However, the payback period is typically 10-20 years due to higher upfront costs. For large families with high hot water usage, savings can be more significant.
Can I replace my tank water heater with tankless myself?
We strongly advise against DIY tankless installations. They require gas line modifications, electrical upgrades, precise venting, and permits. Improper installation can void warranties and create safety hazards. Professional installation ensures code compliance and optimal performance.
How long do tankless water heaters last compared to tank models?
Tankless water heaters last 20-25 years with proper annual maintenance, nearly twice as long as tank models (10-15 years). However, tankless units require annual descaling in areas with hard water like Southwest Washington.
Ready to Upgrade Your Water Heater?
Let our experts help you choose the perfect system for your home. Free estimates and honest advice guaranteed.
Need water heater service in your area? See our Vancouver water heater services, Battle Ground water heater services, or general water heater repair page.